Q1 2024 Earnings Summary
- Gross margins are expected to recover and increase sequentially in the back half of the year, reaching healthy levels above historical averages. This improvement is driven by resolving system integration issues and better margin management.
- Grocery Outlet is introducing approximately 100 new private label SKUs by the end of the year, which are expected to provide better value for customers, enhance margins for both operators and the company, and create another point of differentiation in the assortment.
- The bankruptcy of 99 Cents Only Stores presents an opportunity for Grocery Outlet to acquire additional opportunistic products, potential real estate, and attract new customers and employees, which could enhance sales growth and margins.
- Persistent Systems Integration Issues Impacting Margins and Forecasting: The company's recent systems transition has led to higher-than-anticipated costs and ongoing operational disruptions. In the first quarter, these issues resulted in a gross margin that was 110 basis points below expectations due to unforeseen costs identified during catch-up invoice processing and margin reconciliation. Management admits that "forecasting has been difficult during the system transition as we have not had good visibility to our normal business reporting and tools". There is concern that these disruptions may continue to impact future quarters, raising doubts about the company's operational control and ability to meet financial targets.
- Significant Additional Costs from Commission Support and Residual Expenses: The integration of new systems led to increased expenses, including $12.4 million from commission support provided to operators in the first quarter. Furthermore, the company anticipates additional residual expenses in the second quarter related to the system transition, with estimated costs of approximately $9 million. These ongoing expenses are pressuring margins and could continue to weigh on profitability.
- Risks of Further Unforeseen Costs and Prolonged Disruptions: Despite progress, management acknowledges that the systems issues have been more extensive and prolonged than expected. There is a risk that additional unforeseen problems could arise, potentially leading to further costs and operational challenges. As one analyst questioned, "Is there risk that when that comes back by the end of June that it could be worse than what you had embedded here in your guidance?". Such uncertainties may continue to impact the company's financial performance and cast doubt on management's ability to resolve these issues promptly.
-
Systems Issues and Gross Margin Impact
Q: Will systems issues impact Q2, and when will they be resolved?
A: Management expects residual effects from the systems conversion to impact gross margin by 100 basis points in Q2. Significant financial impacts are expected to be mostly contained to Q2, with normalization in the third and fourth quarters. Ongoing work will continue to enhance systems, but major P&L impacts should diminish after Q2. -
Gross Margin Recovery Outlook
Q: Can gross margin reach 31% or higher after resolving issues?
A: They are confident gross margins will return to normalized levels post-Q2. Underlying business fundamentals are healthy, and margins are expected to sequentially improve in the second half, though not reaching previous highs. They anticipate margins above historical averages. -
Benefit from $0.99 Only Stores Liquidation
Q: How will $0.99 Only Stores' liquidation benefit Grocery Outlet?
A: They anticipate supply opportunities as products previously sold to $0.99 Only become available. Additionally, there may be real estate opportunities and potential to attract new customers and employees in overlapping markets. -
Store Growth Acceleration
Q: What drove the decision to accelerate store growth?
A: Improved management of the opening process allowed for earlier store openings, leading to increased guidance. They are considering opportunistic real estate, including potential sites from $0.99 Only closures, while being mindful of growth rates and operator readiness. -
Commission Support Financial Impact
Q: What's the financial impact of commission support in Q2 and overall?
A: The cumulative impact from systems issues is approximately $65 million, with about half due to commission support. For Q2, they estimate a $9 million impact, around half of which is commission support. They are monitoring inventory counts closely and feel confident in their guidance. -
Private Label Strategy
Q: How will private label products affect pricing and the treasure hunt experience?
A: Introducing private label items will enhance value and margins, offering better value and unique, high-quality products. They plan to include a treasure hunt element by pulsing items in and out, creating excitement without overlapping existing assortments. -
Impact of SNAP Benefit Reductions
Q: How have SNAP reductions impacted the business?
A: The impact is minimal, with customers shifting tender types rather than reducing spending. EBT sales have returned to pre-COVID levels, and their value proposition continues to attract cost-conscious shoppers. -
Comp Breakdown: Traffic vs. Ticket
Q: How did traffic and ticket contribute to comps?
A: Traffic increased by 7%, while average ticket decreased by 2.9% due to lower units per basket amid higher trip frequency and moderating inflation. -
IO Interest at All-Time Highs
Q: Why is independent operator interest at all-time highs?
A: IOs are encouraged by restored store-level reporting and benefits of the new system. The model's appeal—business ownership, independence, and financial upside—continues to attract strong interest, with no loss of confidence related to system disruptions. -
Customer Impact from Systems Issues
Q: What has been the customer impact from systems issues?
A: Minimal impact on customers, with healthy inventory and variety. Systems support daily operations well, and comps were less affected than anticipated. -
Gross Margin Fluctuations Explanation
Q: What caused gross margin fluctuations between quarters?
A: Limited data visibility due to systems issues led to challenges in margin management. The prior quarter's gross margin was unusually high due to factors like existing inventory. Recent pressures are expected to normalize as systems improve, with no other significant costs affecting gross margin. -
IO Pipeline and Future Growth
Q: Have all IOs been selected for upcoming stores, and how is their quality?
A: Not all independent operators have been selected, but the lead time allows for proper recruiting and training. They have a rigorous multi-step process to ensure high-quality operators, setting them up for success and supporting sustained growth.
Research analysts covering Grocery Outlet Holding.